NCAA All-Americans and Qualifiers
| NCAA All-Americans | |||
| Year | Individual | Weight Class | Place |
| 2004 | Rob Rebmann | 125 | 7th |
| 2007 | Ryan Hluschak | 157 | 8th |
| NCAA Qualifiers | ||
| Year | Individual | Weight Class |
| 1957 | John Orr | 137 |
| 1957 | Fred Ulmer | HWT |
| 1980 | Keith Wenger* | HWT |
| 1983 | Phil Gottlick | 142 |
| 1983 | George Kovach* | HWT |
| 1984 | Vinnie Macri | 134 |
| 1985 | Paul Zarbatany* | 118 |
| 1985 | Phil Gottlick | 150 |
| 1985 | George Kovach* | HWT |
| 1986 | Paul Zarbatany* | 126 |
| 1986 | Phil Gottlick | 150 |
| 1986 | George Kovach* | HWT |
| 1987 | Jeff Annesi * | 118 |
| 1987 | Paul Zarbatany* | 126 |
| 1987 | Tim Rothka | 134 |
| 1988 | Tim Rothka | 142 |
| 1990 | Tim Rothka* | 142 |
| 1991 | Owen Hibberd | 126 |
| 1991 | Tim Rothka* | 142 |
| 1992 | Owen Hibberd* | 118 |
| 1992 | Scott Kemp* | 142 |
| 1994 | Corey Padovano* | 126 |
| 1994 | Greg Rosenbaum | 142 |
| 1994 | Rich Evans* | 190 |
| 1995 | Rob Fieo* | 150 |
| 1995 | Josh Stanley | 158 |
| 1995 | Rich Evans* | 190 |
| 1995 | Jamie Huntington* | HWT |
| 1996 | Jamie Huntington | HWT |
| 1998 | Josh Stanley | 167 |
| 1999 | Damien Craighton | 197 |
| 2000 | Ray Stofko* | 157 |
| 2000 | David Dietrich* | 165 |
| 2001 | Chris Jones* | 197 |
| 2002 | Mike Carroll* | HWT |
| 2002 | Chris Jones | 197 |
| 2002 | Rob Rebmann | 125 |
| 2002 | Joe Cristaldi | 133 |
| 2002 | Ben Chunko | 174 |
| 2002 | Pat Miller | 184 |
| 2003 | Mike Carroll* | HWT |
| 2003 | Joe Cristaldi | 133 |
| 2003 | Chris Jones | 197 |
| 2004 | Chris Jones | 197 |
| 2004 | Nick Kozar | 174 |
| 2004 | Joe Cristaldi | 133 |
| 2004 | Rob Rebmann | 125 |
| 2005 | Mark Cartella | 149 |
| 2005 | Chris Cowen* | HWT |
| 2006 | Ryan Hluschak | 174 |
| 2006 | Steve Mytych | 125 |
| 2006 | Jon Oplinger | 197 |
| 2006 | Chris Renninger | 149 |
| 2007 | Chris Cowen | HWT |
| 2007 | Ryan Hluschak | 157 |
| 2007 | Nick Kozar | 174 |
| 2007 | Steve Mytych | 125 |
| 2008 | Ryan Hluschak | 157 |
| 2008 | Steve Mytych | 125 |
| 2009 | Jon Oplinger | 197 |
| 2010 | Steve Mytych* | 133 |
| 2010 | Joe Booth | 157 |
| 2011 | Joe Booth | 165 |
| 2012 | Joe Booth | 165 |
| 2012 | Kyle Frey | HWT |
| 2012 | Brandon Palik | 197 |
| 2013 | Frank Cimato | 141 |
| 2013 | Brandon Palik* | 197 |
| 2014 | Kevin Devoy Jr. | 133 |
| 2014 | Austin Sommer | 157 |
| 2014 | Brandon Palik | 197 |
| 2015 | Kevin Devoy Jr.* | 133 |
| 2015 | David Pearce | 141 |
| 2015 | Matthew Cimato | 149 |
| 2015 | Noel Blanco | 157 |
| 2016 | Matthew Cimato* | 149 |
| 2016 | Zack Fuentes | 125 |
| 2016 | Joey Goodhart | 285 |
| 2017 | Kevin Devoy Jr. | 133 |
| 2017 | Matthew Cimato | 149 |
| 2017 | Alex DeCiantis | 184 |
| 2017 | Joey Goodhart | HWT |
| 2018 | Austin DeSanto | 133 |
| 2018 | Garett Hammond | 157 |
| 2018 | Austin Rose | 174 |
| 2018 | Alex DeCiantis | 184 |
| 2018 | Stephen Loiseau | 197 |
| 2019 | Joey Goodhart | HWT |
| 2019 | Ebed Jarrell | 165 |
| 2019 | Parker Kropman | 149 |
| 2019 | Stephen Loiseau | 197 |
| 2020 | Antonio Mininno | 125 |
| 2020 | Ebed Jarrell | 165 |
| 2020 | Michael O'Malley | 174 |
| 2020 | Bryan McLaughlin | 197 |
| 2021 | Michael O'Malley | 174 |
| 2021 | Parker Kropman | 157 |
| 2021 | Julian Flores | 141 |
| 2021 | Luke Nichter | 149 |
| 2021 | Evan Barczak | 165 |
| 2021 | Bryan McLaughlin | 194 |
| 2022 | Evan Barczak | 165 |
| 2022 | Mickey O'Malley* | 174 |
| 2023 | Brian Bonino | 184 |
| 2023 | Evan Barczak | 165 |
| 2023 | Mickey O'Malley | 174 |
| 2025 | Jordan Soriano | 141 |
| 2025 | Jasiah Queen | 174 |
| 2025 | Mickey O'Malley | 197 |
* Conference champions; other NCAA participants were conference runners-up/placers or at-large selections
